Immigration / Topic

    Accountability & Rights

    We call for accountability at the border and propose a severe penalty for knowingly weakening it. Explore enforcement, rights and the distinction between our proposals and current law.

    EXPLORE THE QUESTIONY / 03
    Accountability for Weakening the Border01

    We propose treating knowingly acting to weaken the border as treason, including for U.S. citizens. Under Article III of the U.S. Constitution, treason consists only of levying war against the United States or adhering to its enemies, giving them aid and comfort. Our proposal is not current treason law; its definition, enforcement and constitutional implementation remain open.

    Due Process & Review02

    A proposal for enforcement needs clear standards, review and protections. In a 2024 report, GAO described immigration court hearings that determine whether noncitizens will be removed; procedures depend on the case. Our proposals do not specify evidence standards, hearings, appeals or legal safeguards.

    Enforcement & Deportation03

    In our public safety pillar, we propose deportation for an undocumented person who commits any crime. This is a proposal, not a description of current law. Our proposal does not define offense categories, the process, safeguards or how it would be implemented.

    Sources & dates

    Last reviewed November 8, 2026

    Explore Y’s frameworks
    Y INSTITUTE